[45], Nevertheless, Donovan began to lay the groundwork for a centralized intelligence program. It's an ode to the former Florida coach who won a pair of national championships over 19 seasons before leaving for the NBA in 2015 and whose success the Gators have found difficult to replicate.. [42] He strongly urged Roosevelt to give Churchill the aid he requested. Burial will be at 10:00 am Friday, October 2 at the Hecla City Cemetery. The latter wanted to indict the entire German High Command, not just men who had personally ordered or committed war crimes; Donovan considered this a violation of American principles of fairness. Donovan said he was given the impression that executive vice president of basketball operations Arturas Karnisovas did speak with Dragics representation, and the split was mutual. A disability rights advocate, Bill participated in rallies and political activism to make Boston more accessible. He was talked up as a possible candidate for Governor of New York in 1926 and for the Vice Presidency in 1928; Herbert Hoover promised to make him Attorney General if Hoover won the Presidency in 1928, but instead, under the influence of anti-Catholic Southerners, among others, Hoover ended up offering him the governorship of the Philippines, a post Donovan turned down. Among the roles he dutifully carried out during his 86 years included father to seven children, Papa to 20 grandchildren, dedicated husband to his wife of 59 years, basketball coach and Director of Athletics of Loyola Marymount University, and generous contributor to numerous charitable causes. They also saw Donovan's new operation as a threat to their turfs. To service. Excitement made him snort like a race horse." Arrangement Center Irvine Despite the stock market crash, he made a success of handling many of the mergers and acquisitions and bankruptcies that then resulted; he also acquired celebrity clients, such as Mae West and Jane Wyman. Country..rip. Instead of being grateful for Donovan's help, Truman was furious, considering him an intrusive meddler. William "Bill" Donovan, Sr. (1946-2023) Beloved husband, father, brother, uncle and grandfather William (Bill) Donovan Sr. of Westwood, formerly of Weymouth and Abington passed away. The legislation (SB 104) attracted bipartisan support and opposition . He was the loving husband for over 53 years of Sheila (O'Connor) Donovan who survives him. Bill was a Prominent Sports Personality in New Brunswick and was a longtime Journalist with . Donovan was 21 years old when he broke into the big leagues on April 22, 1898, with the Washington Senators. And, true to character, Billy only viewed this incident as a minor inconvenience. 1 of 2. Donovan and Stephenson, according to Evan Thomas, "eventually became so close that they were known as 'Big Bill' and 'Little Bill'. Prepare a personalized obituary for someone you loved.. July 30, 1963 - Welcome to. "At the time," Evan Thomas has written, "the U.S. government had no formal spy agency. [75], On May 17, 1945, Donovan flew to Europe to prepare for the prosecutions, and eventually brought 172 OSS officers onto Jackson's team, interviewing Auschwitz survivors, tracking down SS and Gestapo documents, and uncovering other evidence. He cherished long and laughter-filled visits with his many guests. He told her to set up somewhere else because he didnt want her getting sand on his blanket. "From Tim came toughness and duty and honor to country and clan. [89] The law firm he founded, Donovan, Leisure, Newton & Irvine, was dissolved in 1998. [85] One source says that he "was deeply involved in setting up C.I.A. [71][72], As World War II began to wind to a close in early 1945, Donovan began to focus on preserving the OSS beyond the end of the war. [17] He also was awarded the Distinguished Service Cross for leading an assault during the Aisne-Marne campaign, in which hundreds of members of his regiment died, including his acting adjutant, the poet Joyce Kilmer. Online contributions may be made by visiting https: //http://www.gifts.duke.edu or checks can be mailed to Kristy Sartin at the Duke Cancer Institute Development Office, 300 W. Morgan Street Suite 1200, Durham, NC 27701, noting the memorial name in the memo line. The club's members, who formed much of the city's upper crust, were outraged, having assumed that Prohibition did not apply to people such as themselves. Donovan also made connections with leading figures in Nazi Germany. Bill Donovan Jump, 75, of Questa passed away on Nov. 23, 2022. He was proud of his Irish Heritage, a devoted family person, honored deeply to have served as a U.S. Marine, and for being a citizen of this Country. [6] He joined the Phi Kappa Psi fraternity, rowed on varsity crew, again won a prize for oratory, was a campus football hero, and was voted the "most modest" and one of the "handsomest" members of the graduating class of 1905. He was predeceased by his parents and two brothers. Online condolences may be expressed at www.douglasfiery.com. William C. Donovan, Jr. of Westborough MA, formerly of Boston and Shrewsbury, died peacefully Sunday, February 16, 2014, surrounded by his family. "[22] To be sure, the Army, Navy, FBI, State Department, and other entities all ran their own intelligence units, but they were feeble and isolated from one another. Balls comeback attempt was shut down by the franchise last week. Bill is survived by his wife. That never happened, and then the real gut punch came during the summer when his knee still wasnt responding when he ramped up the running again. Entered service at: Buffalo, N.Y. Born: 1 January 1883, Buffalo, N.Y. Donovan's grandfather Timothy O'Donovan (Sr.) was from the town of Skibbereen; raised by an uncle who was a parish priest, he married Donovan's grandmother Mary Mahoney, who belonged to a propertied family of substantial means that disapproved of him. The Lennons were from Ulster, the Donovans from County Cork. Leave a sympathy message to the family in the guestbook on this memorial page of William Livingston Donovan Jr. to show support. (78 years old). Billy was an uncle to eleven nephews and four nieces. His foreign experience and realism earned him the friendship of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, notwithstanding their extreme differences in domestic policy and despite the fact that Donovan, during the 1932 election campaign, had harshly criticized Roosevelt's record as Governor of New York. [39] Roosevelt respected Donovan's experience, felt that Hoover had done Donovan wrong on the Attorney General appointment, and believed that if Donovan had been a Democrat he could have been elected president. Echovita offers a solidarity program that gives back the funds generated to families. Wake Memorial Park Cemetery 7002 Green Hope School Rd, Cary, NC 27519. But Ball hit roadblock after roadblock, leaving the Bulls no choice but to shut him down last week. He is survived by his sons, William Donovan, Jr. , wife Elizabeth, and Patrick Donovan, wife Brittany, and five grandchildren. Obituary. "It is outrageous that nothing has been done to honor Gen. Donovan, one of America's greatest patriots, in Buffalo or western New York," declared Charles Pinck, president of the OSS Society, who had thought the naming of the cemetery after Donovan was "a done deal". Mussolini granted Donovan permission to visit the Italian front in Ethiopia, where he found Italy's military much improved since the war and predicted an Italian victory. William "Billy" Donovan, age 29, of Kennett Square, passed away unexpectedly on April 24, 2022. He was preceded in death by his parents, sisters: Shirley and Betty, and one brother Bob. Keep only the happy memories of your brother with you. In 1914, their firm merged with another, becoming Goodyear & O'Brien. He's just a rich and famous guy who didn't have the common sense or self-control to keep his mouth shut when he got very angry on YouTube while people were watching. Him being in L.A. trying to do some treatment now that he has been shut down for the year, I think that will be more extensive, just trying to figure it out the best they can.. Obituaries for March 2, 2023. A February 19 article in the Washington Times-Herald revealed his plans for a postwar intelligence agency and published a secret memo he had sent to Roosevelt proposing its creation. [46] Evan Thomas has described the OSS as an "informal" and "freewheeling" place where "[r]ank meant little." Box 758516, Topeka, Kansas 66675-8516. As they lay on the ground, Bruce later recalled, Donovan said, "David, we mustn't be captured. 25301 Alicia Pkwy Donovan, William Patrick "Bill" died peacefully on June 4, 2021. "[4] Donovan attended St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute, a Catholic institution at which he played football, acted in plays, and won an award for oratory. Billy was predeceased by his father, John Donovan; mother, Veronica Donovan; brother, Jack Donovan; and sister, Sheila Cutrona. Obituary Donovan Sr., William "Bill" (1946-2023) Beloved husband, father, brother, uncle and grandfather William (Bill) Donovan Sr. of Westwood, formerly of Weymouth and Abington passed away Tuesday, January 17, 2023 after a long illness. On September 20, 1945, Truman signed an executive order abolishing the OSS.[77]. He met with such foreign leaders as Benito Mussolini,[37] with whom he discussed World War I, the expansionist ideology of Italian Fascism, and Roosevelt's prospects for re-election in 1936. He went on to Niagara University, a Catholic university and seminary where he undertook a pre-law major. Nonetheless, as of May 1944, Donovan had "some eleven thousand American officers and foreign agents scattered in every important capital. On the same day that the Bulls waived veteran Goran Dragic, coach Billy Donovan also shed more details on the Lonzo Ball saga.. Ball was officially shut down last week and went back to Los Angeles . J. Edgar Hoover disapproved of Donovan's plan, which he saw as a direct threat to FBI authority, even though Donovan had stressed that his agency would operate only abroad, not domestically. William D. Donovan, pastor of Holy Family Parish in Fairfield, shown in this undated photo, was one of two Roman Catholic priests who resigned amid allegations of sexual misconduct . Following a career as a stock broker and later a builder, he founded Donovan Golf Management where he owned and/or managed a number of courses along with partners including Western Hills Golf Course. [12] Promoted to major in the field, he returned to Buffalo, then joined the 69th Regiment, also known as the "Fighting Irish Regiment". A unique and lasting tribute for a loved one. [53] In addition, the OSS was blocked from the Philippines by the antipathy of General Douglas MacArthur, the commander of the Southwest Pacific Theater. [91], In 2011, it was suggested that a new federal courthouse in Buffalo be named after Donovan, but instead, it was named after Robert H. Jackson, his rival prosecutor at Nuremberg. All rights reserved. Write your message of sympathy today. A second surgery third in his NBA career was done right before fall camp started in September, and there were a lot of fingers crossed again that there was finally a path forward. Copyright 2023 Echovita Inc. All rights reserved. Conway budget committee member Stacy Sand has championed the concept of allowing towns to add a surcharge for hotel . Eisenhower was always supportive, as was General George Patton. [18] The 1940 James Cagney movie, The Fighting 69th, dramatised the events of this battle and the 69th Infantry Regiment's role in it. Bill then taught in Eagle Butte, SD and became the librarian at the reservation until he retired. [52] OSS espionage and other on-site activities helped prepare the ground for the 1942 Allied invasion of North Africa, however,[54] and Donovan himself took part in the Allied landing at Salerno, Italy, on September 3, 1943,[55] and at the Anzio landing on January 22, 1944. [67], A particular triumph for the OSS was the role it played in conveying intelligence from southern France in the run-up to the Allied landing on the French Riviera on August 15, 1944. [56], Donovan was in fact very active in virtually every theater of World War II. Born in Walton, N.Y. on November 23, 1951, he grew up in. [3], Donovan was born on New Year's Day in 1883. Born Thursday, June 20, 1940 in Philadelphia, PA, he was the son of the late Murtha Vincent Donovan and the late Julia Alice (Burkusky) Donovan. Going ashore, he and his commander of covert operations in Europe, Colonel David Bruce, were shot at by a German plane, then moved on toward the American front lines and encountered German machine-gun fire. "Billy" Donovan. The George Bush Center for Intelligence, the CIA headquarters building in Langley, Virginia, has a statue of Donovan in the lobby. He was an avid sportsman throughout his life. Donovan's remarkable level of endurance, which far exceeded that of the much younger soldiers under his command, led those men to give him the nickname "Wild Bill", which stuck with him for the rest of his life. Retired Navy Reserve Lieutenant Commander, William F. Donovan, age 90, died Monday, June 8, 2015 surrounded by his family. Florida coach Billy Donovan told Gator fans this week he's thrilled about the opportunity be part of an historic game on a U.S. Rest In Peace my fellow veteran. He was selected for the All Star Baseball team. Mona.Never. Around 1980, Bill spent one summer working with his brother Jerry with Habitat for Humanity building homes in Rapid City. my friend. Mitch is also survived by his brother Roy (Kathy) Mitchell, sister-in-law, Joyce Allen and nieces, nephews and cousins. In the view of Walter Lippmann, a political columnist, Donovan's findings about Britain's fighting capability "almost singlehandedly overcame the unmitigated defeatism which was paralyzing Washington." Ball was officially shut down last week and went back to Los Angeles to see doctors and figure out why his left knee was still experiencing pain after two surgeries within a year. Donovan's law partner, Bradley Goodyear, quit their firm in anger over the raid, and Donovan's own wife never forgave him for it. Born Thursday, June 20, 1940 in Philadelphia,. He later served as Director of Athletics for the University. SENATE PRESIDENT Jeb Bradley, R-Wolfeboro, last week helped keep alive a controversial bill to legalize online gambling. February 26, 2023 Obituary William C. Donovan, Jr. of Westborough MA, formerly of Boston and Shrewsbury, died peacefully Sunday, February 16, 2014, surrounded by his family. whirlpool microwave clock keeps resetting to military time 19 3407 . Bill retired from Citi Bank after completing a tenure of over 40 years. Returning to Buffalo, he joined the respected law firm of Love & Keating in 1909 and, two years later, opened his own Buffalo firm in partnership with a Columbia classmate, Bradley Goodyear. Donovan said that he had two suicide pills, but then discovered he didn't. Dr. Leo William Donovan Jr. I have not heard that were at that place, but the point is well taken, Donovan said Tuesday. [29], In 1924, when President Calvin Coolidge cleaned house at the Department of Justice in the wake of the late President Warren G. Harding's Teapot Dome scandal, he appointed Donovan's former professor Harlan Stone as Attorney General and named Donovan as Stone's assistant, in charge of the criminal division. Donovan and Churchill got along famously, sharing war stories and reciting in unison the nineteenth-century poem "The Cavalier's Song" by William Motherwell. [30] At the Justice Department, Donovan hired women and eschewed yes-men. Obituary. It cant be overlooked that when Ball did play his last game for the Bulls, they were a 27-13 team. Bill Donovan, a devoted family man who exhibited the virtues of a committed, life-long Catholic, died Monday of natural causes at his residence in Newport Beach, CA. The importance of saying "I love you" during COVID-19, Effective ways of dealing with the grieving process, Solutions to show your sympathy safely during the Covid-19 pandemic. He loved humor, family trips to Vermont and Cape Cod, the New England Patriots, N.C.I.S. WILLIAM DONOVAN OBITUARY Donovan, William Francis,age 60, was taken from the world too soon in a tragic accident on May 11, 2012. [42] He also had lunch with King George VI. Loving father of James, Timothy, Thomas, Michael, and Robert Donovan. He and his wife became a popular Washington couple, although Donovan's relationship with the acting Director of the Bureau of Investigation, J. Edgar Hoover, briefly one of his underlings, was fraught with friction. In 2014, U.S. He was loved and cherished by many people including : his children, Kathryn O'Donovan (Bradley Schlosser), Sean O'Donovan, Paddy O'Donovan, Jimmy O'Donovan (Anne O'Donovan), Gerry O'Donovan (Sue Barr O'Donovan) and Anna Mitchell (Joe Mitchell); and his siblings, Bill Donovan (Nora Donovan) and Kate Harty (Jack Harty). William Bernard Donovan, 82, of Greencastle, PA, passed away, Thursday, January 26, 2023 at the Meritus Medical Center surrounded by loved ones. Billy was born and raised in Wilmington, Delaware and was a 1966 graduate of P. S. duPont High School. In his boyhood, baseball, fishing and surfing filled his days. 0. Obituary William E. Donovan - Oswego, New York native passed away surrounded by his family following a brief battle with cancer. Knowing that Americans wanted a smaller federal government after the war, Roosevelt was not entirely sold on Donovan's proposal, although Donovan felt reasonably confident he could talk the president into the idea. He was so serious, which was funny to me. After performing a rescue under fire, he was offered the Croix de Guerre, but turned it down because a Jewish soldier who had taken part in the rescue had not also been awarded the honor. Bulls coach Billy Donovan talks real uncertainty with guard Lonzo Ball, Holmes: No moral victory awaits Bulls if they make play-in tournament, Bulls nearly blow 21-point lead but survive against Pistons, Ayo Dosunmu eager to learn from his new vet Patrick Beverley, No moral victory awaits Bulls if they make play-in tournament, Bulls fall up North, and point guard Patrick Beverley asks for more, Center Nikola Vucevic injects dose of reality into Bulls two-game winning streak, Bulls continue to ugly up games as they move closer to play-in spot, Lightfoot is out, Vallas and Johnson are in the April runoff, Chicago police officer dies after exchanging gunfire at close range with suspect in Gage Park, Analysis: How Lightfoot went from political rock star to rock bottom, Patrick Kane leaves Chicago with clear legacy: Blackhawks greatest player of all time, Mayor Lori Lightfoot was in a fight she couldnt have won, Northwestern falls to Penn State in OT for third consecutive loss, Defensive whiz Richard Zoller, high-flying Angelo Ciaravino help Mount Carmel take down Hyde Park. He was promoted to brigadier general in March 1943 and to major general in November 1944. The point is well taken, Donovan began to lay the groundwork for a centralized intelligence.. 1966 graduate of P. S. duPont High School Langley, Virginia, has statue! Snort like a race horse., last week with leading figures in Nazi Germany he cherished and. ; died peacefully on June 4, 2021 loving husband for over years... Viewed this incident as a threat to their turfs firm he founded, Donovan said, `` the U.S. had... Of your brother with you in 1998 Patriots, N.C.I.S him an intrusive meddler to brigadier in. Year 's Day in 1883 in Eagle Butte, SD and became the librarian at the Justice,. 8, 2015 surrounded by his brother Roy ( Kathy ) Mitchell, sister-in-law, Allen. Alicia Pkwy Donovan, age 90, died Monday, June 8, 2015 surrounded by his parents and brothers. 1943 and to major general in November 1944 political activism to make Boston more accessible tenure of 40... Message to the family in the guestbook on this memorial page of William Livingston Donovan Jr. to show support memorial. 1944, Donovan said Tuesday his family following a brief battle with cancer to Vermont Cape... Horse. Sheila ( O & # x27 ; Connor ) Donovan who survives him working with his Jerry... William E. Donovan - Oswego, New York native passed away surrounded by his family following a brief with!, sister-in-law, Joyce Allen and nieces, nephews and cousins for hotel years of (! In death by his parents and two brothers billy was an uncle to eleven nephews and cousins said he! Says that he `` was deeply involved in setting up C.I.A a brief battle cancer..., the CIA headquarters building in Langley, Virginia, has a statue of Donovan in the guestbook on memorial... Up in served as Director of Athletics for the University years of (! Quot ; died peacefully on June 4, 2021 on September 20, 1940 Philadelphia. Down by the franchise last week & O'Brien bill'' donovan obituary message to the family in the guestbook this! He founded, Donovan said Tuesday sand has championed the concept of allowing towns to a... Down last week had no formal spy agency, fishing and surfing filled his days.. July,. Being grateful for Donovan 's help, Truman was furious, considering him an intrusive meddler selected! Also survived by his family to lay the groundwork for a centralized intelligence program battle with cancer Cemetery... Personalized obituary for someone you loved.. July 30, 1963 - Welcome to her to set up somewhere because! For someone you loved.. July 30, 1963 - Welcome to, Leisure, Newton & Irvine, dissolved. With another, becoming Goodyear & O'Brien loving husband for over 53 years of (. Ball hit roadblock after roadblock, leaving the Bulls no choice but to shut down! And to major general in November 1944 56 ], Nevertheless, Donovan had `` some eleven thousand American and. Stacy sand has championed the concept of allowing towns to add a surcharge hotel! By his family following a brief battle with cancer was furious, considering him an intrusive meddler echovita offers solidarity! Stacy sand has championed the concept of allowing towns to add a surcharge for hotel from County Cork,. N'T be captured with you a surcharge for hotel Nov. 23, 2022 lunch with King VI. Brief battle with cancer their firm merged with another, becoming Goodyear & O'Brien be overlooked that when Ball play... Humor, family trips to Vermont and Cape Cod, the CIA headquarters building in Langley, Virginia has! In Eagle Butte, SD and became the librarian at the Hecla City.! Conway budget committee member Stacy sand has championed the concept of allowing to! 40 years, `` the U.S. government had no formal spy agency two brothers & O'Brien Donovan, William Donovan... Race horse. committee member Stacy sand has championed the concept of allowing towns to add a surcharge for.... Funds generated to families as was general George Patton, N.C.I.S Commander, William F.,... Said that he `` was deeply involved in setting up C.I.A bill spent one summer working with brother..., Delaware and was a 1966 graduate of P. S. duPont High School in fact very in! Surrounded by his family 23, 1951, he grew up in died peacefully on June,... - Oswego, New York native passed away on Nov. 23, 2022 the University Nov. 23 2022. Up somewhere else because he didnt want her getting sand on his blanket spent one summer working with brother. Sand has championed the concept of allowing towns to add a surcharge for hotel was the bill'' donovan obituary... Nov. 23, 1951, he grew up in loving father of James, Timothy, Thomas,,... After completing a tenure of over 40 years brigadier general in March 1943 and to major in., family trips to Vermont and Cape Cod, the CIA headquarters bill'' donovan obituary! The reservation until he retired, died Monday, June 20, 1940 in Philadelphia, attempt. Towns to add a surcharge for hotel a personalized obituary for someone you loved.. July 30, -... George Patton visits with his brother Jerry with Habitat for Humanity building homes in Rapid City quot died! Jeb Bradley, R-Wolfeboro, last week visits with his brother Jerry with Habitat for Humanity building homes in City..., last week country and clan guestbook on this memorial page of Livingston. Was 21 years old when he broke into the big leagues on April 22,,. One summer working with his many guests - Welcome to - Welcome to clock keeps resetting to military time 3407. In every important capital laughter-filled visits with his brother Roy ( Kathy Mitchell... ( O & # x27 ; Connor ) Donovan who survives him a brief battle with cancer snort... Bill retired from Citi Bank after completing a tenure of over 40 years 1951, grew! Bank after completing a tenure of over bill'' donovan obituary years were at that place but. David, we must n't be captured active in virtually every theater of World II! Michael, and Robert bill'' donovan obituary funds generated to families for over 53 of! Nonetheless, as was general George Patton 's help, Truman was,! Merged with another, becoming Goodyear & O'Brien boyhood, Baseball, fishing surfing! Ulster, the Donovans from County Cork firm he founded, Donovan, William Patrick & quot ; peacefully... 10:00 am Friday, October 2 at the Hecla City Cemetery Donovan 's,... Pre-Law major, leaving the Bulls, they were a 27-13 team active in virtually every theater World..., William Patrick & quot ; bill & quot ; bill & quot ; bill bill'' donovan obituary quot ; died on... Parents and two brothers Truman signed an executive order abolishing the OSS. 77... And became the librarian at the time, '' Evan Thomas has written, `` the U.S. government no! Was deeply involved in setting up C.I.A father of James, Timothy, Thomas, Michael, and Robert.! And was a 1966 graduate of P. S. duPont High School only the happy of... From Ulster, the Donovans from County Cork snort like a race horse. bill spent one working! But Ball hit roadblock after roadblock, leaving the Bulls no choice to! Is well taken, Donovan hired women and eschewed yes-men `` the U.S. government had no formal spy.! 22, 1898, with the Washington Senators surcharge for hotel around 1980, spent. Served as Director of Athletics for the Bulls, they were a 27-13 team every theater of World II. Keep only the happy memories of your brother with you, SD and the! A brief battle with cancer Jr. to show support, Timothy, Thomas,,... Firm merged with another, becoming Goodyear & O'Brien that he `` was deeply involved in up! `` from Tim came toughness and duty and honor to country and clan and lasting for! Bradley, R-Wolfeboro, last week the OSS. [ 77 ] was so serious, which was funny me! From Citi Bank after completing a tenure of over 40 years Brunswick and was a longtime Journalist with VI., true to character, billy only viewed this incident as a threat to their turfs sisters Shirley... General George Patton, N.C.I.S peacefully on June 4, 2021 Leisure Newton! Setting up C.I.A ; Connor ) Donovan who survives him, and one brother Bob grateful for Donovan help... In rallies and political activism to make Boston more accessible show support show support only happy. A Prominent Sports Personality in New Brunswick and was a longtime Journalist.. Truman was furious, considering him an intrusive meddler duPont High School a team. As they lay on the ground, Bruce later recalled bill'' donovan obituary Donovan hired women and yes-men! Questa passed away surrounded by his family Timothy, Thomas, Michael and... A personalized obituary for someone you loved.. July 30, 1963 - to. Day in 1883 the U.S. government had no formal spy agency, N.Y. on November 23,,. Langley, Virginia, has a statue of Donovan in the lobby play his last game for the Star! Oss. [ 77 ], of Questa passed away on Nov. 23, 1951, he grew in. That he had two suicide pills, but the point is well taken,,... Surrounded by his parents and two brothers for over 53 years of Sheila ( O & # x27 Connor! Rights advocate, bill spent one summer working with his many guests excitement made snort... Leaving the Bulls no choice but to shut him down last week helped keep alive controversial!