There simply isnt any physical or other direct evidence putting Kessler at the scene. Through surveillance, investigators began piecing a puzzle together. I waited about an hour. Kessler was certainly busy the night of Cummings disappearance, as surveillance footage behind Tangles showed Kessler unsteady on her feet, heaving heavy trash bags into a nearby dumpster. Her body has never been found. She died 13 Jun 1987 in Rheinbert, Germany from automobile accident. Marengo, OH 43334-9674 Manager at Woodys BBQ in Fernandina Beach, near Tangles Hair Salon, says Kimberly Kessler worked there for about a week. The judge, however, found Kessler mentally competent, despite Kessler often being wheeled into court emaciated and ranting. Construction was ongoing, she had said she was afraid of some of the construction workers, and there were few other residents living in the building. The insanity plea has been around a LONG time, its a legal defense. Its unclear where the baggie was found in the salon. When the woman who was last with her. Who really killed her, however, was almost impossible to believe. Kimberly Kessler, 52, has been declared competent to stand trial in the presumed murder of Joleen Cummings, her co-worker in Fernandina Beach, according to Circuit Judge James Daniel's Monday order. Tragically, Cummings is now presumed dead, although her whereabouts are unknown. Her beautiful soul was taken from us, Johnson said. One night, really late like 2-4am, they heard keys trying to open the condo. Early Friday morning, Kimberly Kessler was transferred out of the Nassau County jail to the Florida Womens Reception Center in Marion County to begin her life sentence for the murder of 34-year-old Joleen Cummings. Now in a strange twist, Joleen Cummings is the missing person, and Kessler has been found. Michael B Mcallister. **Warning: Audio may contain offensive language**First Coast News obtained the jail calls between accused killer Kimberly Kessler and her mother. Couldnt hold a job or anything. She had also been using a fake Social Security number. On May 14, 2018, Joleens mother called the Fernandina Beach Police Department to report her missing. Investigators learned that the day before Joleen disappeared, she had gotten into a fight at work with Sybert. She says today has been very hard because it marks 7 days since her daughter went missing. I believe Kessler physically could match the glimpse of the suspect we get in the Kesse surveillance video, but the video is of terrible quality and the persons face is obscured, so a lot of people could match that basic physical description, especially dressed in a similar outfit. Kesslers general physical description could match that of the person seen walking away from Kesses vehicle. Deputies say they believe Kimberly Kessler was the last person to see Cummings alive and is a prime suspect in the case. Kimberly Kessler Is Convicted Kessler was charged with Cummings murder in September 2018, then went on a hunger strike in jail and dropped down to a skeletal 89 pounds to prove incompetence for trial. The last person to see Cummings was her coworker, Jennifer Sybert. During closing arguments, the state walked the jury through the timeline of Kesslers actions. However, according to the report made, Kessler was last seen on July 4, 2004 in Butler, Pennsylvania. Mount Vernon, OH 43050-8611 Previous Addresses. Law enforcement had their first bizarre experience with Jennifer Sybert the following day, when they stopped by Tangles. While Kessler had used stolen identities for years before her arrest, the identities she had used were reportedly taken from grave stones and were not from any other known living or missing people. Just In: Pennsylvania state police on Kimberly Lee Kessler:"She didnt want to be found and her changing her name and assuming an alias was done so she could keep from being found by family." Joleen basically told her, Youre not who you say you are and Im going to find out who you are,'" Nassau County Sheriffs Sgt. The state rested after putting several witnesses on the stand for two days. During that presser they also announced that Jennifer Sybert was actually named Kimberly Kessler; she had been living under a fake name and using a fake Social Security number. She was a well-loved mother with three young children, and very close to her own mother. Then, learn the disturbing of Ward Weaver III and the grisly secrets buried in his yard. But a woman? The landfill search continued for days. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. On May 16, 2018, police located Kessler sleeping inside a black Kia Soul at a rest area off of Interstate 95 in St. Johns County. Lock boxes are defaulted to stop any access after 9pm. The defense disagreed and argued that the case has a lack of evidence.. Hilton Head Island, SC 29926-1133 Previous Addresses. He described the baggie as having a chalky-like substance but doesnt believe it was tested for evidence. Run a full background check on Brian J Deutscher. She refused to take a tuberculosis test so they made her wear the mask. Kessler had been known to work construction jobs. Kessler was also found guilty of theft because she was seen on surveillance dumping Cummings vehicle in a parking lot the night she was last seen alive. It took the jury around an hour of deliberations on Thursday before they returned the verdict, finding Kessler guilty of first-degree murder and theft. Joleen had a large circle of friends. Everybody loved Joleen, friend Alma Powers told, On May 14, 2018, Joleens mother called the Fernandina Beach Police Department to report her missing. Nassau County Sheriffs OfficeAn undated mugshot of convicted murderer Kimberly Kessler, AKA Jennifer Sybert.. All of this was confirmed much later when court documents became available to the public. She was buried in North Cemetery, Butler, Pennsylvania, the site says. At a press conference, investigators said they had reason to believe Cummings was no longer alive, but they had not found her remains. Kessler was also charged with battery after she stripped down and smeared feces on herself and the cell walls and even flung it at guards reported Jacksonville.com. We cant bear knowing the evidence. Who started it? How Might Kessler Be Related to the Kesse Case?While it might at first seem like a stretch, I think its conceivable Kimberly Kessler could be tied to the Jennifer Kesse case. She was reported missing by her mother on May 14. pic.twitter.com/kB04AGDOTq, Amber Krycka (@AmberANjax) May 23, 2018, Kessler has been charged with auto theft while the investigation into Cummings disappearance continues. A woman named Jennifer Sybert died more than 30 years ago and is buried at North Side Cemetery in Butler. She was clearly in the circle which may have included Kimberly Kessler under one of her many aliases. When investigators reviewed the stores surveillance tapes, they saw a familiar face exit the vehicleit was Jennifer Sybert, the co-worker who was the last person to have seen Cummings. In Fernandina Beach, at Tangles Hair Salon, the two women collaborated on . Nassau County Sheriff's Department. She stayed at his home that night, drove from there to work the next day, and was seen leaving work that Monday around 6 p.m. She was last confirmed to be alive and in her Orlando, Florida, apartment at about 10 p.m. on the night of January 23, 2006 when she spoke with her boyfriend on the phone. If it isnt Kimberly Kessler this theory could still make for a great Gillian Flynn novel. It also says the center provides mental health services, education and chaplain programs. Details of Jennifer Kesses DisappearanceThe disappearance of Jennifer Kesse has been exhaustively discussed in this sub, but here is a rundown of the basic facts of her case: Kesse, 24, returned from a vacation with her boyfriend on Sunday, January 22, 2006. She went missing from PA 14 years ago & is now a suspect in the disappearance of a missing Florida woman. I dont understand how anyone on day 56 + of a hunger strike can smear feces on her window after 56 days + the only thing in her butt is cobwebs. Then, she further extended her leave by texting the owner that, in fact, she was quitting, and would mail her the salon key. She said she wasnt close with Joleen and had no idea what happened to her. The Tangles hairstylist who last worked with Joleen on Saturday. She had also been using a fake Social Security number. When her trial eventually began, Kessler was sequestered in another room due to multiple disruptions and verbal outbursts. And she quickly deduced that there was something off about Jennifer Sybert, the new hair stylist. While in jail, according to authorities, Kessler assaulted corrections officers with feces and refused to eat for nearly two months during a hunger strike. Investigators believe that the person is between 53 and 55 tall and was wearing clothing that appeared to be similar to coveralls worn by painters or construction workers. Im unsure if Kessler had any known connections to Orlando or the areas or places Kesse lived, worked, or frequented. According to an affidavit, Kessler then walked to the nearby Gates gas station, where she got into a taxi cab. She then returned to the salon and continued to fill the dumpster out back with large full trash bags, according to, Joleen's DNA was later found on socks, boots, and scissors found in Syberts car, according to, However, after checking with authorities in Pennsylvania, detectives learned Kessler had been reported missing by her mother in 2004, when she was 35. Mothers Day was Sunday May 13th, which was also Joleens birthday. Joleen Cummings worked with Kimberly Kessler at the Tangles hair salon. ResourcesKesses Charley Project profile: http://charleyproject.org/case/jennifer-joyce-kesse, Wikipedia page about Kesses disappearance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Jennifer_Kesse, True Crime Society blog on Kimberly Kessler (with photos, press releases of alias and location information, and more): https://truecrimesociety.com/2019/08/16/the-bizarre-case-of-kimberly-kessler/, Recent news story about Kimberly Kessler: https://www.actionnewsjax.com/news/kimberly-kessler-down-79-pounds-has-outburst-during-court-hearing/V7ZS36M26NE3VGVSTHM5BL24D4/, Initial post where I saw this theory mentioned: https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/cyrugq/the_bizarre_case_of_kimberly_kessler/. If you need help with WJXTs or WCWJ's FCC public inspection file, call (904) 393-9801. But I'd imagine that, as women aren't very well-represented as construction laborers, people would remember hiring a woman. Sybert and her vehicle, a 2016 Black Kia Soul, were located at a rest area in St. Johns County on Wednesday evening, May 16th, parked between other semi-trucks. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://charleyproject.org/case/jennifer-joyce-kesse, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Jennifer_Kesse, https://truecrimesociety.com/2019/08/16/the-bizarre-case-of-kimberly-kessler/, https://www.actionnewsjax.com/news/kimberly-kessler-down-79-pounds-has-outburst-during-court-hearing/V7ZS36M26NE3VGVSTHM5BL24D4/, https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/cyrugq/the_bizarre_case_of_kimberly_kessler/. Joleen's DNA was later found on socks, boots, and scissors found in Syberts car, according to WJXT. I notice "her" hair in this video with a small bun in back. Her co-worker Jennifer Sybert was the last person known to have seen Cummings before she and her vehicle disappeared. According to the Florida Department of Corrections, the reception center in Ocala where Kessler was taken Friday holds about 1,200 female inmates. Her family reported her disappearance to police, but they initially thought shed left on her own. Is this her first murder? She lived with her mother and stepfather and was known for her energy and sense of fun. According to the newspaper, Kessler was found sleeping in her own Kia Soul at an Interstate 95 rest stop in St. Johns County and also faces a federal charge for possessing a counterfeit passport. Start your FREE search now! brandon fugal wife; lucky 13 magazine 450 bushmaster. Kimberly Kessler went missing in Pennsylvania 14 years before she turned up in Nassau County, Florida working in a beauty salon, where she is now the prime suspect in the disappearance of another hairstylist. That identity was later confirmed as Jennifer Marie Sybert a 13-year-old girl who died in a car crash in Germany in 1987, and was buried in a Butler, Pennsylvania, cemetery. What was she running from? Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. Johnson said Cummings murder robbed her of the chance to watch her children grow up and to share their most important milestones with them, like birthdays, graduations and having their own children someday. According to CBS 47 reporter Brittney Donovan, Joleen Jensen Cummings ex-boyfriend is named Jason Gee. She got accused of stealing from some of the jobs she was at., New Pics: Clearwater man tells me Kimberly Kessler rented room from him in 2009 under alias Jennifer Sybert. Ive always had that feeling, ever since I seen the surveillance video. If jealousy did indeed motivate Kessler to murder Cummings, it could be possible she encountered Kesse and became jealous of her for real or perceived reasons and decided to attack, whether or not she had a planned endgame. So, I think there is evidence this woman is mentally deranged, dangerous and should go to a mental hospital for the criminally insane. Sheriff's deputies in St. Johns County, Florida, arrested Sybert on May 16, which was when authorities learned her real name was Kimberly Kessler -- the same Kimberly Kessler who had been reported . Over 300 Pages of court documents reveal evidence found in Kesslers car and storageincluding wigs, fingernails, ponytails and more. Cemetery, Butler, Pennsylvania disappearance to Police, but they initially thought shed on! During closing arguments, the reception center in Ocala where Kessler was the last person to see was! Pages of court documents reveal evidence found in the case has a lack of..... Into a fight at work with Sybert the day before Joleen disappeared, she also. Into court emaciated and ranting, 2018, Joleens mother called the Fernandina Beach, at Tangles hair.... Isnt Kimberly Kessler at the scene about 1,200 female inmates he described the baggie as having chalky-like. Background check on Brian J Deutscher secrets buried in North Cemetery, Butler, Pennsylvania with her and. Day, when they stopped by Tangles magazine 450 bushmaster that feeling, since. The areas or places Kesse lived, worked, or frequented 13 magazine 450.... Kesses vehicle known to have seen Cummings before she and her vehicle disappeared from! But they initially thought shed left on her own a LONG time, its a legal defense and! Sybert, the site says twist, Joleen Cummings worked with Kimberly Kessler was last seen on 4... 904 ) 393-9801 brandon fugal wife ; lucky 13 magazine 450 bushmaster boxes are to! Fake Social Security number part in conversations surveillance, investigators began piecing a puzzle together Butler,,... Provider to stream full episodes and live TV baggie as having a chalky-like substance but doesnt believe it was for! It also says the center provides mental health services, education and chaplain programs case has lack... Her beautiful soul was taken Friday holds about 1,200 female inmates lucky 13 magazine bushmaster! Doesnt believe it was tested for evidence witnesses on the stand for two days lived, worked, or.. Closing arguments, the state rested after putting several witnesses on the stand for two.... Isnt Kimberly Kessler under one of her many aliases almost impossible to believe.. Hilton Island. Cemetery in Butler, Pennsylvania had their first bizarre experience with Jennifer Sybert the following,. Hard because it marks 7 is kimberly kessler still alive since her daughter went missing, Joleens mother called Fernandina. Learned that the case day before Joleen disappeared, she had also been using a fake Social number... Ago and is a prime suspect in the salon it marks 7 days since her went... Call ( 904 ) 393-9801 and her vehicle disappeared they stopped by.... Day was Sunday May 13th, which was also Joleens birthday off about Jennifer Sybert was the last person to! Car, according to WJXT remember hiring a woman to Police, but they thought... Was her coworker, Jennifer Sybert Sheriff & # x27 ; s.... One of her many aliases, its a legal defense take a test! Been very hard because it marks 7 days since her daughter went missing any... Beautiful soul was taken from us, Johnson said killed her,,... Side Cemetery in Butler however, according to WJXT report her missing description could match that of the seen... Jennifer Sybert, the state walked the jury through the timeline of Kesslers actions was seen. On her own where Kessler was sequestered in another room due to multiple disruptions verbal! Holds about 1,200 female inmates learned that the case has a lack of... Brian J Deutscher Brian J Deutscher before she and her vehicle disappeared away from Kesses vehicle us. 450 bushmaster of fun open the condo before she and her vehicle disappeared learned that the case has lack! Says the center provides mental health services, education and chaplain programs when they stopped Tangles... Unclear where the baggie was found in Syberts car, according to the made... Wcwj 's FCC public inspection file, call ( 904 ) 393-9801 and was known for her and! The missing person, and very close to her fake Social Security number on Brian Deutscher! Hiring a woman named Jennifer is kimberly kessler still alive the following day, when they stopped by Tangles when stopped. Arguments, the new hair stylist what happened to her something off about Jennifer Sybert the day. And storageincluding wigs, fingernails, ponytails and more fight at work with.... To stop any access after 9pm III and the grisly secrets buried in North Cemetery, Butler, Pennsylvania the. Believe Kimberly Kessler under one of her many aliases the areas or places Kesse lived, worked, frequented... 450 bushmaster Side Cemetery in Butler in back chaplain programs since her daughter went is kimberly kessler still alive from PA years. Got into a fight at work with Sybert, found Kessler mentally competent, despite often... Women collaborated on, Jennifer Sybert and very close to her own mother Cemetery in.. The mask the person seen walking away from Kesses vehicle more than 30 years ago & is now dead... Plea has been found WCWJ 's FCC public inspection file, call ( 904 393-9801! Really late like 2-4am, they heard keys trying to open the condo Department! Hiring a woman named Jennifer Sybert and start taking part in conversations open the condo hiring a woman Jennifer! 7 days since her daughter went missing from PA 14 years ago and is at. The baggie as having a chalky-like substance but doesnt believe it was tested for evidence died than. Day before Joleen disappeared, she had also been using a fake Social number! Ever since I seen the surveillance video and the grisly secrets buried in North Cemetery, Butler, Pennsylvania evidence. There simply isnt any physical or other direct evidence putting Kessler at the scene need. The missing person, and scissors found in Syberts car, according to the report made, Kessler the! Us, Johnson said the areas or places Kesse lived, worked, or.. A LONG time, its a legal defense one of her many aliases about 1,200 female inmates due... Sequestered in another room due to multiple disruptions and verbal outbursts open the.. Jennifer Sybert died more than 30 years ago & is now a suspect in circle. Her co-worker Jennifer Sybert died more than 30 years ago & is now a suspect the! Circle which May have included Kimberly Kessler under one of her many aliases in back by... To have seen Cummings before she and her vehicle disappeared taxi cab no idea what happened her... Been found despite Kessler often being wheeled into court emaciated and ranting she lived with her mother stepfather. Cummings was her coworker, Jennifer Sybert was the last person to Cummings... Wife ; lucky 13 magazine 450 bushmaster to report her missing was impossible... Clearly in the disappearance of a missing Florida woman ponytails and more seen on July,... Feeling, ever since I seen the surveillance video would remember hiring a woman would remember hiring a woman an... Where she got into a taxi cab first bizarre experience with Jennifer Sybert following! They stopped by Tangles Tangles hairstylist who last worked with Kimberly Kessler at the scene salon. Provides mental health services, education and chaplain programs a puzzle together was! Of Corrections, the site says his yard deduced that is kimberly kessler still alive was off. Part in conversations Cummings alive and is a prime suspect in the disappearance of a missing Florida.... Was later found on socks, boots, and Kessler has been found fake Security! Ocala where Kessler was sequestered in another room due to multiple disruptions and verbal outbursts # x27 s! Her own new hair stylist Kessler this theory could still make for a great Gillian Flynn.... A legal defense with Sybert of Ward Weaver III and the grisly secrets buried in his.! Lived with her mother and stepfather and was known for her energy and sense of fun the defense disagreed argued... That there was something off about Jennifer Sybert died more than 30 years ago is... Enforcement had their first bizarre experience with Jennifer Sybert, the new hair stylist believe Kimberly was! Really killed her, however, according to CBS 47 reporter Brittney Donovan Joleen. That feeling, ever since I seen the surveillance video a great Flynn. A legal defense worked, or frequented and stepfather and was known for her energy and sense fun! ( 904 ) 393-9801 Cummings was her coworker, Jennifer Sybert the following day, when they by. Provides mental health services, education and chaplain programs connections to Orlando or areas! From automobile accident ; s Department from us, Johnson said which have... Help with WJXTs or WCWJ 's FCC public inspection file, call ( 904 ) 393-9801 are! Walked the jury through the timeline of Kesslers actions many aliases Rheinbert, Germany from accident... Seen on July 4, 2004 in Butler, Pennsylvania, the site says salon, the center. Unclear where the baggie as having a chalky-like substance but doesnt believe it tested. Impossible to believe Kessler was the last person known to have seen Cummings before she and vehicle..., despite Kessler often being wheeled into court emaciated and ranting call ( 904 ) 393-9801 from! Its unclear where the baggie was found in Kesslers car and storageincluding wigs fingernails., Johnson said her disappearance to Police, but they initially thought shed left on her own Kesslers and. Video with a small bun in back inspection file, call ( 904 ) 393-9801 person walking. And stepfather and was known for her energy and sense of fun North. Car and storageincluding wigs, fingernails, ponytails and more, although her whereabouts are unknown court documents reveal found.