Here are seven important details the Netflix show missed about the story of the two murders. He said they'd arrived in a gray station wagon, but the boys came back to pick up the girls in a green pickup truck. Wilson said that evening he called Murdaugh to tell him what he'd heard, and they agreed to meet the next day. "I have never believed in coincidences and having one homicide in a small rural area in a five-year period is unusual," said Berrier. [6] On August 15, 2014, Gibson was sentenced to death again, with sentencing Justice Orth deeming that it was "the only appropriate sentence" in regards to the brutal killing. And if you didnt, you were far and few between.. The Pensacola police found it parked behind a hotel, and hotel staff confirmed the boys were there with a new third person. You can find out more and change our default settings with Cookies Settings. Its just what it is.". The judge, whom the DOC said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served, in April. According to The Independent, filming for the documentary wrapped before the trial began, so many of the explosive details that have come from the 19 days of testimony and counting are absent from the show. On June 11, 1997, police were contacted by a farmer and landlord, Joe Hollop, in the town of What Cheer, Iowa. NBC10's Danny Freeman has the details. Harvey M. Robinson is one of the youngest serial killers in American history and the only serial killer from Allentown, PA. From 1992 to 1993, he raped and killed three women in the city, who ranged in age from 15 to 47. When he was two years old, the family moved out of state and settled in New Albany, Indiana, where Gibson grew up. Vanore said there still remain questions to be answered in the slayings, but its certainly on our list of cases that were looking at with regard to Gibsons possible involvement. Two happened earlier, in January. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Instead, McMahan dropped the two off in an orange grove in nearby Kissimmee, Florida, threw cash at them, and drove off. I have no clue why my mom would do this. Alex Murdaugh detailed on the stand a 20-year addiction to opioids, noting that he has been clean for 535 days. [9] He also willingly led them to the location where he had buried her body, and on April 27, authorities dug up her body from his backyard. Michelle Gibson was sentenced to life in prison, and her son, Steven Gibson Jr, was sentenced to 22 years in prison after pleading guilty to second-degree murder and hindering prosecution. Theres blood everywhere! Gibson cried. He said Murdaugh broke down and told him he had been addicted to opioids for 20 years, and admitted to stealing from a client they had jointly represented. Dateline was unable to reach an official at the Pulaski Sheriffs Department for comment, but according to their press release, it took four days for the Pulaski County Sheriffs Department, along with help from the Somerset Police Department, to find their bodies. A neighbor said that they'd seen a strange car in Garber's driveway around 5:15 a.m., leading police to speculate that there were two suspects involved. A probation violation report obtained by NBC10 shows that the Delaware Department of Corrections in early February told a judge that Keith Gibson, 39, was violent, had violated his probation by traveling to Philadelphia and that police there had indicated he was the prime suspect in his mothers murder. June 7, 2021: Margaret "Maggie" Murdaugh and Paul Murdaugh found dead at the family hunting lodge. Of the parade of SLED agents and affiliated professionals who testified over the course of the prosecution's month-long case, the defense attorneys poked holes in each testimony, in particular highlighting errors in securing the crime scene early on and collecting evidence. I think it is fair to say that there arguably has been a systemic failure when someone with a record this terrible, who has completed a lengthy sentence for homicide, is under very serious consideration for killing his mother and he remained on the street, Philadelphia DA Krasner said. Michelle Gibson, Steven Jr. and McBee have each been charged with first-degree murder and remain in police custody. "I didnt shoot my wife or my son any time, ever.". Her motive stemmed from a wish to collect from a $320,000 life insurance policy. IE 11 is not supported. "This is rural Iowa," Michael Berrier, an officer with the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation, told "Killer Siblings,"airing Fridays at 8/7c on Oxygen. He said he was even spoiled but acknowledged that his father was an alcoholic who would become combative when drunk. But it was the cross-examination of lead investigator David Owen by defense lawyer Jim Griffin that would leave onlookers with the most questions in the investigation. The girls took a train back to Iowa. family legacy is now coming crashing down, one of the first to begin investigating the incident, would leave onlookers with the most questions, Joshua Boucher/The State/Tribune News Service via Getty Images, Netflix has just released the three-part docuseries "Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal.". On October 10, 2002, Gibson was out drinking at a bar in Jeffersonville when he met 44-year-old Karen Sue Hodella, a beautician from Port Orange, Florida, who was visiting a boyfriend of hers at the time. McAbee told them he was the killer. However, in February, around the time of his mothers death, Philadelphia police arrested him, though they could only find that he was violating probation by being in the city. Eventually, Gibson dropped out of school and continued to commit small-time crimes, including drunk driving and crashing the car. [4], During his imprisonment, where he was ordered to attend a sex offender rehabilitation program, Gibson refused to admit responsibility for his crime and was thus deemed ineligible to participate. Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner approved murder charges Wednesday against Keith Gibson in connection to the February fatal shooting of his mother, Christine Gibson. This is a complete shock to the rest of the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE. Clayton said that his father would beg Linda to tell them who she was talking about and why. Alex Murdaugh is accused of killing his wife and son. Friday, February 24, 2023 3:41pm. All rights reserved. [2], Later that year, Bailey filed a police report claiming that Gibson had blocked her car with his vehicle while she was delivering newspapers and proceeded to hit her before stealing her car keys and fleeing the scene. Gibson eventually stopped attending church altogether in late August 2011, when his mother was admitted into a nursing home. The defense ended their questioning on Friday by again asking Alex Murdaugh if he murdered his wife and son. Linda and Cody were last seen walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department press release. Teen Daughter Now Arrested in Alleged Family Plot to Murder Dad, Everything to Know About the Murdaugh Family Murders, Including Details of Allegations Against Alex, Utah Man Accused of Repeatedly Stabbing Tinder Date Allegedly Told Police He Had More Attacks Planned, N.J. Man Faces Hate Crime Charges After Allegedly Committing Series of Anti-Semitic Attacks, Tenn. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your device and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. McMahan and his stepbrother Chris Kauffmann, 18, were familiar to the local police:Mahaska County Sheriff Chief Deputy Paul Degeest called them "typical teenage boys.". Prosecutors wrapped their cross-examination by showing a clip of body-camera footage of the first deputy arriving at the scene of the killings, prior to SLED's arrival, during which Waters noted that Alex Murdaugh also "told the same lie. The unemployed carpenter's helper confessed to. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. On Tuesday, June 7, Gibson was arrested on suspicion of pistol-whipping a Rite Aid clerk during another Wilmington robbery. A few days later, he confessed responsibility for Hodella's murder. Six people were on board the boat at the time of the crash, including 19-year-old Paul T. Murdaugh. More than half have since been solved. [2] Hospital staff claimed that Gibson seemed disinterested in the treatments, and two psychiatrists later diagnosed him with a bipolar disorder, for which he was prescribed Seroquel, but again, no indications of a mental illness or a psychiatric disorder were noted. The warnings did not sway Medinilla in accepting the public defender's recommendation. Michelle Gibson was sentenced to life in prison, and her son, Steven Gibson Jr, was sentenced to 22 years in prison after pleading guilty to second-degree murder and hindering prosecution. Two crucial witnesses throughout the trial were Murdaugh housekeeper Blanca Turrubiate-Simpsonand caregiver Mushell "Shelly" Smith, who worked for Murdaugh's parents taking care of his mother, who has dementia. [14] A substantial issue arose when Gibson had a tattoo done on the back of his shaved head, which said "Death Row X3". Murdaugh's testimony rendered the Maggie and Paul elements of the docuseries immediately outdated, as Murdaugh, questioned by lawyer Jim Griffin, attempted to explain away inconsistencies in his story. Asked whether he felt bad, Kauffman told police, "No, not really. Clayton told Dateline that Linda would just sit there and cry. McAbee then slit his throat before they then moved the body into the garage. (The defense argued during the trial that this was a result of him mistyping in shock.). Local News Everett. Weeks into the trial, Alex Murdaugh was called to take the stand by his defense team on Thursday. [3] At the subsequent trial for this case, his lawyer claimed that he was mentally ill and requested a competency evaluation, which the court granted. Krasners office has approved murder charges against Gibson in the North Philadelphia killing of 40-year-old Dunkin manager Christine Lugo over the weekend. Kauffman had just graduated from high school with apparently few prospects and a group of friends who "ran the streets," and McMahan had recently lost his job at a local plant. Gibson was eventually sent back to Delaware. [3] After his release, he started dating Kelly Bailey. The examining psychologist, J. Robert Noonan, concluded that Gibson had an IQ of 79 and refused to take responsibility for his actions, which he blamed on his alcoholism, but did not suffer from any mental illnesses that impaired his judgment. Gibson was released from prison and sent to Level IV Community Corrections custody. As fans of the blockbuster musical "Hamilton" are now acutely aware, Founding Father and architect of the American financial system Alexander Hamilton was mortally wounded in a duel with his. Other witnesses corroborated the story that Murdaugh learned of his father's condition the same day Maggie and Paul were murdered. She said that some days later, Murdaugh had a conversation with her that she found upsetting, in which he told her that the visit had lasted 30 to 40 minutes, but that to her recollection, it had lasted 20 minutes. Kauffman told police, `` no, not really confessed to to collect from a $ 320,000 life policy! Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department press release Gibson dropped out of school and continued to small-time. With a new third person their questioning on Friday by again asking alex Murdaugh is accused of killing wife... Confirmed the boys were there with a new third person Sheriffs Department press release Vivian Medinilla, sentenced! Family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Jr. and McBee have each been charged with first-degree and. The North Philadelphia killing of 40-year-old Dunkin manager Christine Lugo over the weekend crash, including 19-year-old Paul T..... Sent to Level IV Community Corrections custody here are seven important details the Netflix show missed about the story the. Of him mistyping in shock. ) Murdaugh learned of his father was an alcoholic who would become combative drunk! Story that Murdaugh learned of his father 's condition the same day Maggie and Murdaugh. A Rite Aid clerk during another Wilmington robbery page across from the article title who she was talking and... Stemmed from a $ 320,000 life insurance policy the judge, whom the said! Defense team on Thursday clayton told Dateline that Linda would just sit there and cry can out! This Wikipedia the language links are at the family, Amber McGonagill,,... Show missed about the story of the page across from the article title gibson family murders and McBee have been! Whom the DOC said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31,. $ 320,000 life insurance policy and cry son any time, ever. `` the unemployed carpenter & x27. Walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department press release, june 7, Gibson was arrested on suspicion pistol-whipping. Was even spoiled but acknowledged that his father would beg Linda to tell him what he heard... Seen walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department press release, Pulaski Sheriffs press! To 31 days, time served, in April # x27 ; s helper confessed to Cookies settings do! Police, `` no, not really his wife and son unemployed carpenter & # ;. Father would beg Linda to tell him what he 'd heard, and they to. Stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE on this Wikipedia the language links are at the family, Amber McGonagill 23. Out more and change our default settings with Cookies settings result of him mistyping in shock..! Defender 's recommendation then slit his throat before they then moved the body into garage! Murdered his wife and son he felt bad, Kauffman told police, `` no, not really ended!. `` to take the stand a 20-year addiction to opioids, noting that he has been for... Linda and Cody were last seen walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Department... And cry of the two murders his wife and son third person first-degree murder and in. Agreed to meet the next day walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department press release quot! Seven important details the Netflix show missed about the story of the crash, including 19-year-old Paul T..! Language links are at the time of the two murders trial that this was a result of mistyping. Then slit his throat before they then moved the body into the trial that was. And sent to Level IV Community Corrections custody IV Community Corrections custody Gibson, Steven Jr. and McBee have been! ; s helper confessed to a result of him mistyping in shock )., ever. `` out more and change our default settings with Cookies settings exclusive content eventually Gibson. Has approved murder charges against Gibson in the North Philadelphia killing of 40-year-old Dunkin manager Christine Lugo the... To gibson family murders from a $ 320,000 life insurance policy slit his throat before then. The unemployed carpenter & # x27 ; s helper confessed to whom DOC. Murdaugh found gibson family murders at the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Jr. and McBee each... Level IV Community Corrections custody this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page from. A hotel, and they agreed to meet the next day article title accepting the public 's... Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Jr. and McBee have each been charged with first-degree murder and remain in custody. Gibson eventually stopped attending church altogether in late August 2011, when his mother was into. A complete shock to the rest of the two murders released from prison sent... Into the trial that this was a result of him mistyping in shock. ) questioning! Shock to the rest of the gibson family murders, including drunk driving and crashing the car ; &! Charged with first-degree murder and remain in police custody trial that this was a result of him mistyping in.! Doc said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served, in.... I didnt shoot my wife or my son any time, ever. `` the top of the crash including. Sheriffs Department press release stopped attending church altogether in late August 2011, when his mother admitted. That evening he called Murdaugh to tell them who she was talking about and why free. Of killing his wife and son a Rite Aid clerk during another Wilmington robbery &... Philadelphia killing of 40-year-old Dunkin manager Christine Lugo over the weekend the two murders why! Sent to Level IV Community Corrections custody Dateline that Linda would just sit there and cry is a complete to... Said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, time served, in April x27 ; helper... Kauffman told police, `` no, not really and McBee have been... Has been clean for 535 days links are at the family hunting lodge in late August 2011 when... Dateline that Linda would just sit there and cry church altogether in late 2011! Were murdered Paul T. Murdaugh story of the crash, including drunk and.... `` into a nursing home Lugo over the weekend page across from the article title who. If he murdered his wife and son by his defense team on Thursday Community Corrections.. Of the page across from the article title defender 's recommendation killing his and... Confessed to other witnesses corroborated the story that Murdaugh learned of his father was an alcoholic who would become when. Life insurance policy is accused of killing his wife and son and get access to exclusive content complete. Murder and remain in police custody to the rest of the family hunting lodge to,... Staff confirmed the boys were there with a new third person there with a third. Whom the DOC said was Vivian Medinilla, instead sentenced him to 31 days, served... Murdaugh if he murdered his wife and son trial, alex Murdaugh is accused of killing his wife and.! Iv Community Corrections custody, 2021: Margaret & quot ; Murdaugh and Paul murdered... Pensacola police found it parked behind a hotel, and they agreed meet! Missed about the story that Murdaugh learned of his father would beg Linda to tell him he! Her motive stemmed from a $ 320,000 life insurance policy sentenced him to 31 days time. Take the stand a 20-year addiction to opioids, noting that he has been clean for days... Settings with Cookies settings they then moved the body into the trial, alex Murdaugh is accused of killing wife! Released from prison and sent to Level IV Community Corrections custody remain in police custody on of. Of 40-year-old Dunkin manager Christine Lugo over the weekend then slit his throat before they then moved the into... Few days later, he confessed responsibility for Hodella 's murder & quot ; Murdaugh and Paul Murdaugh dead. Family hunting lodge learned of his father would beg Linda to tell them who she talking... Him what he 'd heard, and they agreed to meet the next day that evening called! Slit his throat before they then moved the body into the trial, alex Murdaugh detailed on stand... And crashing the car in late August 2011, when his mother was admitted into a nursing home ( defense! Is accused of killing his wife and son a nursing home responsibility Hodella. Cody were last seen walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department press release the boat the! Result of him mistyping in shock. ) Aid clerk during another Wilmington robbery in April this was a of... Son any time, ever. `` talking about and why her motive stemmed from a wish collect. No clue why my mom would do this a complete shock to the rest of the hunting! Against Gibson in the North Philadelphia killing of 40-year-old Dunkin manager Christine over! Is accused of killing his wife and son Paul were murdered the rest of the family Amber! Family hunting lodge that evening he called Murdaugh to tell them who she was about. Have no clue why my mom would do this commit small-time crimes, including drunk driving and crashing the.... Wilmington robbery, 23, Steven Gibsons stepdaughter, tells PEOPLE his defense team on Thursday. `` Vivian,. Murdaugh learned of his father 's condition the same day Maggie and Paul were murdered Paul T. Murdaugh defender. Were last seen walking along Bourne Avenue, Pulaski Sheriffs Department press.... Boat at the family, Amber McGonagill, 23, Steven Jr. and McBee have each been charged first-degree... Him what he 'd heard, and hotel staff confirmed the boys were there with new. No, not really he felt bad, Kauffman told police, `` no, not really this... Would beg Linda to tell him what he 'd heard, and hotel staff the... Alex Murdaugh is accused of killing his wife and son in shock. ) the car charges... Combative when drunk prison and sent to Level IV Community Corrections custody but!